Performance Incentives Within Firms: The Effect of Managerial Responsibility

We examine the distribution of incentives across executives with explicit divisional responsibilities, those with broad oversight authority over the firm, and CEOs. Oversight executives have pay-performance incentives that are $1.22 per thousand dollar increase in shareholder wealth higher than those of divisional executives. For CEOs, incentives are $5.65 per thousand higher than for executives with divisional responsibility. The aggregate pay-firm performance sensitivity of the top management team is substantial, at $32.32 per thousand for the median firm. CEO incentives are 42 to 58 percent of the aggregate incentives to the top management team. We match a subset of our divisional executives to the divisions they manage. We document a positive pay-divisional performance sensitivity and show that it is increasing in the precision of the divisional performance measure. The pay-firm performance sensitivity for divisional executives is decreasing in the precision of their divisional performance measure. These results are consistent with a principal-agent model with multiple signals of managerial effort.